MIT AI Risk Repository · Risk Sub-Category · 54.03.01
Specification gaming
Category: Harm caused by unaligned competent systems
Description
"AI systems game specifications [305]. For example, in 2017 an OpenAI robot trained to grasp a ball via human feedback from a xed viewpoint learned that it was easier to pretend to grasp the ball by placing its hand between the camera and the target object, as this was easier to learn than actually grasping the ball [103]."
From Ten Hard Problems in Artificial Intelligence We Must Get Right (Leech2024 ), as extracted by the MIT AI Risk Repository (CC BY 4.0).
Classification
- Causal entity
- AI
- Intent
- Intentional
- Timing
- Other
Subdomain definition: AI systems acting in conflict with human goals or values, especially the goals of designers or users, or ethical standards. These misaligned behaviors may be introduced by humans during design and development, such as through reward hacking and goal misgeneralisation, or may result from AI using dangerous capabilities such as manipulation, deception, situational awareness to seek power, self-proliferate, or achieve other goals.
Real-world incidents in this subdomain
- Reinforcement Learning Reward Functions in Video Games
- Predictive Policing Program by Florida Sheriff’s Office Allegedly Violated Residents’ Rights and Targeted Children of Vulnerable Groups
- Image Classification of Battle Tanks
How other frameworks describe this risk
- Natural Language Underspecifies Goals
- Loss of control
- Loss of control
- Sudden loss of control
- AI leads to humans losing control of the future
- Risks from delegating decision-making power to misaligned AIs
- Risks from AIs developing goals and values that are different from humans
- Future AI systems might actively reduce human control
Other entries from Leech2024
- Negative impacts of AI use
- Under-recognized work
- Environmental cost
- Discrimination, toxicity, and bias
- Privacy
- Security
- Harm caused by incompetent systems
- Harm caused by unaligned competent systems
- Emergent goals
- Deceptive alignment
- Within-country issues: domestic inequality
- Demographic diversity of researchers