AI Decision Explanation and Appeal Kit
Using this in a product? Commercial use is allowed under CC BY 4.0, with attribution. Ask about an SLA-backed feed or a white-label licence.
On this page 7 sections
In brief
The AI Decision Explanation and Appeal Kit is a free DOCX and XLSX kit for EU AI Act and Colorado ADMT law (SB 26-189). Version v5, built 12 November 2026, cites 26 recorded duties from 16 instruments, each linked to its official source. It is written for deployer / user organisation, provider / developer and public authority / government body.
- Format
- DOCX and XLSX · Kit
- Version
- v5, built 12 Nov 2026
- Duties cited
- 38 from 16 instruments
- Rows from the records
- 13
- Frameworks
- EU AI Act, Colorado ADMT law (SB 26-189)
- Written for
- Deployer / user organisation, Provider / developer, Public authority / government body
- Price and licence
- Free · CC BY 4.0
What's inside
- Notice and explanation letter templates
- Human review procedure
- Request log with days-taken formula
- Explanation and appeal duties across every jurisdiction on record
Preview
The sheets and sections of version v5, as built. Columns marked ▾ have a dropdown; ƒ is a formula.
Sheet: Requests log
| Reference | Received | AI system | Request ▾ | Reply due | Replied | Days taken ƒ | Outcome ▾ | Human reviewer | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rows are yours to fill; the dropdowns, formulas and colour rules are already in place. | |||||||||
Every request from a person about an AI-assisted decision, with the time taken to answer it. Set the reply-due date from the rule that applies to you.
Sheet: Explanation and appeal duties
| Duty | Category | Instrument | Jurisdiction | Who it binds | Nature | Source reference | Applies from | What it requires | Evidence a reviewer expects | ISO/IEC 42001 | NIST AI RMF | Verification | Record |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Provide contestability, supply-chain transparency and records (guardrails 7 to 9) | Vendor and supply-chain governance | Australian Voluntary AI Safety Standard | Australia | Deployer / user organisation, Provider / developer | Voluntary | Guardrails 7, 8 and 9 | Establish processes for people impacted by AI to challenge use or outcomes; be transparent with other organisations across the AI supply chain about data, model | AI system register and supplier disclosures | GOVERN 6.x | Pending review · source-linked | https://aipolicytracker.org/obligations/australia-vaiss-contestability-supply-chain-records | ||
| Let consumers opt out of automated decision-making technology for significant decisions, or offer a qualifying human appeal | Human oversight | California CPPA automated decision-making rules | California (United States) | Deployer / user organisation | Legal requirement | Cal. Code Regs. tit. 11, § 7221 | 2027-01-01 | Consumers must be able to opt out of the use of ADMT for a significant decision, through at least two designated methods that are easy to use and need minimal s | The opt-out link, form and second method, and a log of requests with dates received and processing stopped; Notices sent to service providers and contractors ab | Pending review · source-linked | https://aipolicytracker.org/obligations/us-california-ccpa-admt-opt-out | ||
| Answer consumers' requests to access information about how automated decision-making technology was used about them | Transparency and disclosure | California CPPA automated decision-making rules | California (United States) | Deployer / user organisation | Legal requirement | Cal. Code Regs. tit. 11, § 7222 | 2027-01-01 | On a verified request, the business must explain in plain language the specific purpose for which it used ADMT about the consumer; the logic of the ADMT, enough | An access-response template per system and a log of requests answered; Contract terms requiring vendors to assist with access requests | Pending review · source-linked | https://aipolicytracker.org/obligations/us-california-ccpa-admt-access | ||
| Disclose the use of the technology and the principal reasons after an adverse consequential decision | Transparency and disclosure | Colorado ADMT law (SB 26-189) | Colorado (United States) | Deployer / user organisation | Legal requirement | 2027-01-01 | After an adverse consequential decision, the deployer must tell the consumer that automated decision-making technology was used, give the principal reasons for | Pending review · source-linked | https://aipolicytracker.org/obligations/us-colorado-admt-adverse-decision-disclosure | ||||
| Offer meaningful human review of an adverse consequential decision | Human oversight | Colorado ADMT law (SB 26-189) | Colorado (United States) | Deployer / user organisation | Legal requirement | 2027-01-01 | A consumer who receives an adverse consequential decision may obtain meaningful review by a person with the authority and information to change the outcome. Sco | Pending review · source-linked | https://aipolicytracker.org/obligations/us-colorado-admt-human-review | ||||
| Deployers must tell natural persons that a high-risk AI system is used in decisions about them | Transparency and disclosure | EU AI Act | European Union | Deployer / user organisation, Public authority / government body | Legal requirement | Article 26(11) | 2027-12-02 | Deployers of Annex III high-risk AI systems that take decisions about natural persons, or help take them, must inform those persons that they are subject to the | Affected-person notice template and placement record | Annex A.8.5 | GOVERN 5.1, MANAGE 4.1 | Verified against the official source 26 Sep 2026 | https://aipolicytracker.org/obligations/eu-ai-act-art-26-11-notice-to-affected-persons |
The recorded duties served by an explanation and appeal route, across every jurisdiction on record.
Document outline (DOCX)
- Adverse decision explanation and appeal kit
- Adverse decision notice (template)
- Explanation reply (template)
- Human review procedure
- Duties on record
- Provide contestability, supply-chain transparency and records (guardrails 7 to 9)
- Let consumers opt out of automated decision-making technology for significant decisions, or offer a qualifying human appeal
- Answer consumers' requests to access information about how automated decision-making technology was used about them
- Disclose the use of the technology and the principal reasons after an adverse consequential decision
- Offer meaningful human review of an adverse consequential decision
- Deployers must tell natural persons that a high-risk AI system is used in decisions about them
- Deployers must explain individual decisions taken with high-risk AI on request
- Employers and employment agencies must let candidates request an alternative selection process or accommodation
- Operators of high-impact AI must be able to explain outputs and the main criteria behind them
- Respect the right to object to automated decision-making without human intervention
- Provide appropriate transparency and explainability
- Provide routes to contest AI outcomes and seek redress
- Apply safeguards to solely automated decisions with significant effects
How to use it
- 1Request the files. Enter your name, company and work email in the form on this page. The DOCX and XLSX download links arrive by email and work for 7 days.
- 2Read the README page. It states the version (v5), the dataset it was built from and the licence, so anyone reviewing your copy knows which records it reflects.
- 3Fill in your rows. Complete the "Requests log" sheet for your own systems. Dropdowns, formulas and colour rules are already set.
- 4Check the duties against your situation. The "Explanation and appeal duties" sheet lists the recorded duties with their source references. Mark which apply to you and follow each link to the official text.
- 5Complete the document. Work through the DOCX sections (Adverse decision explanation and appeal kit, Duties on record) and replace each placeholder with your organisation's answer.
- 6Keep the evidence and watch for new versions. Link each completed row to the evidence that supports it. When the law on record changes, this template gets a new version and a changelog on this page.
Duties this template covers (38)
Each is cited in the file with its source reference and a link back to the record.
- Test and monitor systems, enable human control, and be transparent with users (guardrails 4 to 6)
- Give consumers a Pre-use Notice before using automated decision-making technology for a significant decision
- Let consumers opt out of automated decision-making technology for significant decisions, or offer a qualifying human appeal
- Answer consumers' requests to access information about how automated decision-making technology was used about them
- Frontier developers must publish a transparency report before deploying a new frontier model
- Notify consumers before automated decision-making technology influences a consequential decision
- Disclose the use of the technology and the principal reasons after an adverse consequential decision
- Offer meaningful human review of an adverse consequential decision
- Provide deployers with clear instructions for use
- Enable and assign effective human oversight
- Disclose AI interaction and label synthetic content
- Employers must inform workers and their representatives before using high-risk AI at work
Legal basis
Version history
| Version | Built | Dataset | What changed |
|---|---|---|---|
| v5 | ef1018b7a6a2 | Dataset 4559f86f527b → ef1018b7a6a2. Sheet "Explanation and appeal duties": 11 → 13 rows (+2). Document: 73 → 85 blocks. Record citations: 22 → 26. | |
| v4 | 4559f86f527b | Dataset 1e8ea28a8a93 → 4559f86f527b. | |
| v3 | 1e8ea28a8a93 | Dataset 52bd836b1d6b → 1e8ea28a8a93. | |
| v2 | 52bd836b1d6b | Dataset c6967b988bb5 → 52bd836b1d6b. | |
| v1 | c6967b988bb5 | First version, built from dataset c6967b988bb5. |
Only the latest version is served. A rebuild that changes the content adds a version; a rebuild that does not is skipped.
Frequently asked questions
What is in the AI Decision Explanation and Appeal Kit?
Notice and explanation letter templates. Human review procedure. Request log with days-taken formula. Explanation and appeal duties across every jurisdiction on record.
Which duties does it cite?
38 recorded duties from Australian Voluntary AI Safety Standard, California CPPA automated decision-making rules, California SB 53 and Colorado ADMT law (SB 26-189), including Guardrails 4, 5 and 6, Cal. Code Regs. tit. 11, § 7220, Cal. Code Regs. tit. 11, § 7221, Cal. Code Regs. tit. 11, § 7222, Business and Professions Code Section 22757.12 (as added by SB 53) and Article 13. Each row links to the record, and the record to the official source.
Who is it for?
The duties it cites fall on deployer / user organisation, provider / developer and public authority / government body. Whoever owns AI governance for those roles usually completes it, with the system owner supplying the facts.
Is it free?
Yes. Request the DOCX and XLSX with your work email on this page; the download links arrive by email, valid for 7 days. No account and no charge. Licensed CC BY 4.0. You may use, adapt and share this template, including commercially, with attribution to aipolicytracker.org.
How will I know when it changes?
Version v5 was built on 12 November 2026. The library is rebuilt daily; when a change to the records reaches this template it gets the next version, a changelog below and an entry in the templates feed.
Is there a self-assessment that goes with it?
Yes: the AI Transparency & Disclosure Assessment (20 questions, about 5 minutes) and the Algorithmic Bias & Fairness Assessment (23 questions, about 6 minutes). They are free and run on Certifyi, a related product. A score is a self-check, not an audit; this template is where the work it points to gets written down.
Does completing it make us compliant?
No. It is an informational resource, not legal advice; it helps produce the evidence a regulator, customer or auditor asks for. Whether a duty applies to you is a judgement the template cannot make.
Disclaimer: informational only, not legal advice. Verify every claim against the linked official sources and consult a qualified lawyer before acting.